Romance novel notes from 2008

There were the 3 Georgian historicals I liked, but thought were fairly flawed and Almost A Gentleman, the one erotic Georgian I couldn’t finish. I did, however, really enjoy The Bookseller’s Daughter and The Slightest Provocation, so I’ll give the author the benefit of the doubt no matter what.

Then there are the ones on the sidebar to the right, some of which are romance.
Under My Skin by Jenny Gilliam, which I liked enough that I only stopped reading when I had to tend to various obligations, like Tax Deductions 1 and 2. And congrats to her for its sale to Amira! (A little late on that congrats, Jenny. Mea culpa.)
51rfl2hj3nl_ss500_
Catch Of The Day
by Kristan Higgins, which made me bawl and laugh and cringe in vicarious embarrassment, which was only cute/sweet because it wasn’t happening to me. Also, her Just One Of The Guys, which was good but not as heartwrenching as Catch of the Day. Her first effort, Fools Rush In (which I actually read in 2009, sorry!), I found at a thrift store for a quarter and damme if that wasn’t a bargain! All 3 books are written in first person, though Catch of the Day and Just One of the Guys are in present tense (I like!) and Fools Rush In was in past tense. (I crack myself up.) You must have a box of Kleenex for these books. I remember this author’s name. For me, that’s like saying her books are auto-buy and lo and behold! She’s got a new title, Too Good To Be True. Honestly, I think she’s more what people call “women’s fiction” because she seems to focus more on the heroine’s journey than the romance. Word of warning: Don’t glom this author.

Eva Gale’s short stories “Desperate Measures” and “Scorpion’s Orchid” (post-apoc/steampunk). Loved both, though not crazy about short story format (that’s my own failing); the short form worked better in “Scorpion’s Orchid.” And, oh, you must, must, must, must, MUST go catch Eva’s free reads. “The Seduction of Gabriel Stewart” was wonderful and part of what I want to read, as both a spiritual and sexual woman: a smooth meld of the erotic and the faithful.

Susan Elizabeth Phillips’s Natural Born Charmer. Of course I read it straight through, but SEP’s losing her grip on me, I think. Not sure why because she’s got a book on my keeper shelf and in this one, though the heroine was an artist, she wasn’t flighty and she was quick to catch on to what was going on around her, so I was good with that.

Patti Shenberger’s The Captain’s Wench. I’m a sucker for seamen (heh) stories, but this story suffered from some logical fallacies like the fact that the heroine just accepted the strange man in her house was a ghost and bantered with him as if he were an old friend. Like there’s really nothing strange about that situation at all. It was a short story/novella, so it could’ve been a word length requirement problem.

I read The Dragon Earl, which I really enjoyed. The first chapter on the author’s website got me enough that I remembered it when I saw it at Wal-Mart.

Forbidden Shores didn’t impress me. I never felt like any of the characters actually loved each other and that the HEA (happily ever after) was forced.

The following has spoilers. Highlight the blank spaces to read.

51opq4gipvl_ss500_Last but not least, this: A Mermaid’s Kiss by Joey W. Hill. I don’t know what to say about this because I’m conflicted in so many directions, yet it’s stuck with me ever since I read it. I hesitate to do a review on it, but here I am 3 months later, still thinking about it. It’s supposed to be erotic. It’s not. The reasoning for the sex between the hero and heroine is flimsy at best, though I wasn’t any more put off by the more, ah, unusual aspects of it than I was by any of the other sex scenes, none of which were necessary to the story. (The hero and heroine have sex with her in mermaid form and her in pixie form.) I also didn’t like the fact that the heroine had so many configurations (mermaid, pixie, human). The sex just…annoyed me. Why? Because I thought this was a terribly spiritual book with underpinnings of faith (some amalgam of Christianity and goddess mythos) and a keen insight on human behavior. In a lot of ways, its underlying theme reminded me of Dogma, although in a gut-wrenching way and not a satiric way. The sex got in the way of the character development (and worldbuilding) and pulled me out the story every single time. And it wasn’t even good sex.

It took me a while to write this post and 2008 was a busy year, but the ones I forgot must not have made an impact on me.

2 thoughts on “Romance novel notes from 2008

  • January 14, 2009 at 8:01 am
    Permalink

    Thank you! What a nice way to start the day!

    I liked Natural Born Charmer, but my fave of SEP was Ain’t She Sweet and it made me everloving faithful in one scene. When Sugar Beth waitresses a party with the Willows, a group of women she used to be queen of.

    I had such mexed feelings about Cacth of the Day (apart from the WRONG cover. I’ve been to Maine and I say *pfft* on the beach shot. I stayed in the house across the street from where they shot King’s The Storm right by the Swans Island Ferry). I think you are right, it’s more woman’s fiction and although I loved Malone, the heroine made me cringe just a little too much. But on your rec, I will go pick up her others.

    And have you ever read any of Pam’s other work writing as Molly Weatherfeild? Carrie’s Story? It’s a modern classic I tells ya. I actually gave my copy to Eden Bradley years ago.

    You know, I’m like the actors who can’t watch their own movies in that I can’t re read a story once it’s out there. But I’ll have to go re read @ Gabriel and figure out why they ring everyone’s bells.

    Reply
  • January 14, 2009 at 9:06 am
    Permalink

    I wouldn’t’a said it if I didn’t mean it.

    My favorite SEP is the “circus” book. It’s on my keeper shelf.

    With Catch of the Day, I liked that she was someone more foolish than I, though I did get impatient with her unwillingness to confront people about their tittering. My only real complaint with Higgins is she doesn’t show the men very well. I knew from the beginning she’d end up with Malone, but I wanted to know him better.

    No, I didn’t know Pam wrote as anybody else, but putting those on my TBR list. Thanks!

    Reply

Leave a Reply to Eva Gale Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *